Google Review Rules for Contractors: Ask Every Customer


Your five-star reviews aren’t as safe as you think.

In July 2025, a business owner told the Better Business Bureau that a marketing company got their Google profile suspended. Their words: “3 years of hard work and fifteen 5 star reviews lost because of them.” The complaint doesn’t say what the marketing company did. It doesn’t have to. Reviews take years to earn and one bad shortcut to lose.

That’s the part nobody mentions when they pitch you a review trick. Google blocked or removed over 292 million reviews that broke its rules in 2025. And in the U.S., the FTC can now fine a business over fake reviews.

The good news: the rules fit on a sticky note. You can ask every customer. You can’t pay them, pick them, or tell them what to write.

TL;DR: Ask every customer for a Google review, by text, the day the job’s done. Google bans paying for reviews, asking only happy customers and telling people what to write (Google Maps content policy). Get caught and Google can stop new reviews, hide your old ones and post a warning on your profile (Google Business Profile Help). The FTC can fine up to $53,088 per violation (FTC, Dec 2025). Asking works: 65 in 100 people wrote a review when asked (BrightLocal, 2026).

Can you ask customers for Google reviews?

Yes. In BrightLocal’s 2026 survey of 1,002 American adults, 78 in 100 got asked for a review in the past year, and 65 in 100 wrote one when someone asked (BrightLocal, Feb 2026). Asking is normal. Your customers expect it, and good reviews keep selling for you while your quote sits on the kitchen table. You’ll find that side in how contractors close more estimates.

Google is fine with it too. Its policy lets you ask for reviews of a real job, “without offering incentives to do so or attempting to influence the rating or the contents of the review” (Google Maps content policy).

Read that line twice. Asking is fine. Paying, picking and steering are not. That’s where guys get burned.

Can you pay or reward customers for reviews?

No. Google’s policy bans offering “payment, discounts, free goods and/or services” for a review (Google Maps content policy). Google’s help pages call it “fake & misleading content” that’s “strictly prohibited” (Google Business Profile Help).

The U.S. government has a rule on it now too. The FTC’s review rule went into effect on October 21, 2024. It bans rewards “conditioned on the writing of consumer reviews expressing a particular sentiment, either positive or negative” (FTC, Aug 2024). The FTC says fines can run “up to $53,088 per violation” (FTC, Dec 2025).

So a free filter change for a 5-star review breaks both. A free filter change for any review still breaks Google’s. A prize draw for everyone who leaves a review is still something in exchange for a review. Skip all of it.

What is review gating, and why does it get you flagged?

Review gating is asking only your happy customers. Google bans it in plain words: you can’t “discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers” (Google Maps content policy). In the 2026 Local Search Ranking Factors survey, experts list “reports of review gating” as #22 on their list of things that hurt local rankings (Whitespark, Nov 2025). That’s expert opinion, not a Google statement.

Here’s what gating looks like in real life. A text goes out: “How did we do? Rate us 1 to 5.” Fours and fives get your Google link. Ones, twos and threes get a private form instead. If your review text works like that, it’s gating, and it’s the exact setup you need to rip out.

The FTC weighs in too. Its own Q&A says gating isn’t named in its rule, “but this practice could violate the FTC Act” (FTC).

Fixing an unhappy customer is fine. Call them. Make it right. Just send them the same Google link everyone else gets. The line is simple: you never hold back the link because of how they feel.

Can you tell customers what to write?

No. Reviews with real words in them count: experts rank the number of Google reviews with text #9 among Map Pack factors (Whitespark, Nov 2025). But Google’s policy says you shouldn’t “request that specific content be included” (Google Maps content policy).

That kills an old local SEO trick. No “mention the panel upgrade.” No “say you’re from Red Deer.” No “give a shout out to Mike.” Google also bans asking staff to collect reviews “that include specific content, including content that identifies a staff member.”

You can name the job in your ask. “Thanks for having us out for the furnace swap” is fine. Telling them what to put in the review isn’t.

Can your crew or your family review your business?

No. Google put posting limits on more than 782,000 accounts that broke its rules in 2025 (Google, Apr 2026). Reviews from people with a conflict of interest break them. Google’s policy names “current or former employment, a contractual or consultory relationship, or other professional or personal affiliations” (Google Maps content policy).

So no reviews from your crew, your sub, your brother-in-law or the supplier you buy from. And no review quotas: Google bans “requesting that staff solicit a certain number of reviews.”

In Canada, the Competition Bureau warned in 2024 that “anyone who writes or permits writing reviews that give a false or misleading impression to consumers could be liable under the Competition Act” (Competition Bureau Canada, Jan 2024). It also says employees “must disclose all connections they have with the business.”

What happens if Google catches you?

Google blocked or removed over 292 million reviews that broke its rules in 2025, and took down more than 13 million fake business profiles (Google, Apr 2026). It isn’t only cleaning up spam. It goes after the business too.

Google lists what it can do to your profile (Google Business Profile Help):

  1. Your profile “will not be able to receive new reviews or ratings for set period of time.”
  2. Your existing reviews “will be unpublished for set period of time.”
  3. Your profile can “display a warning” telling people that Google took fake reviews down.

Picture that last one. A homeowner taps your listing and sees a warning about fake reviews before she sees your work. Ranking got you seen. That banner sends her to the next guy. Google says it will email you before it puts a restriction on your profile, so read anything from Google Business Profile the day it lands.

How often should you ask for reviews?

After every job. In BrightLocal’s 2026 survey, 74 in 100 people look for reviews from the last three months, and 32 in 100 want ones from the last two weeks (BrightLocal, Feb 2026). Old reviews don’t sell much.

Ranking points the same way. Experts rank “sustained influx of reviews over time” #14 among Map Pack factors. They also list “receiving too many Google reviews too fast” as a negative (Whitespark, Nov 2025). Sterling Sky, a local SEO firm, warns rankings can “fall off a cliff” if reviews stop for even three weeks (Sterling Sky, 2025). That’s their field view. Google doesn’t confirm review timing as a ranking factor.

So skip the review blitz where you text 300 old customers in one week. A steady trickle from every finished job beats a pile that shows up all at once. For how reviews fit into ranking overall, read how contractors rank in the Google Map Pack.

How do you ask for reviews the right way?

Use the Clean Ask. Asking works: 65 in 100 people wrote a review when asked (BrightLocal, Feb 2026). The Clean Ask has four rules. The first three come straight from Google’s policy. The fourth keeps your reviews fresh:

  1. Every customer. Same text after every finished job. No sorting the happy ones from the grumpy ones.
  2. Nothing for it. No freebies, no gift cards, no prize draws.
  3. No script. Name the job if you like. Never tell them what to say.
  4. Every week. Send it the day the job’s done, so reviews come in all year, not in bursts.

Here’s a text you can copy:

“Hi Sarah, thanks for having us out for the furnace swap today. If you’ve got a minute, would you leave us a Google review? Here’s the link: [your review link]. Thanks, Mike”

That’s it. Setting it up takes an afternoon. If there’s no review in three or four days, send one friendly reminder. Then stop. Ask for a referral in the same moment if the job went well; the contractor referral system shows you how.

Picture the payoff. A homeowner taps your listing at 9 p.m. and sees three reviews from this month, each one about a real job like hers. She calls you, not the guy whose newest review is from last spring.

Then answer every review, good and bad. 89 in 100 people expect owners to respond (BrightLocal, 2026). AI tools read those reviews and replies too, which is part of how contractors get recommended by ChatGPT.

The honest bit

Going clean costs you something. 68 in 100 people will only use a business with four stars or more (BrightLocal, 2026), and the Clean Ask sends your link to the cranky customer too. You’ll get some threes. A gate would have hidden them. That’s the price of keeping every review you earn.

And a clean setup can still sit dead. In May 2026, an electrical contractor on an Apex build had the review text set up exactly like this. It got zero reviews. Why? All 53 of the leads in the CRM were still sitting at “new lead.” The text only fired when a job got marked done, and none ever was. So tie your ask to something that happens anyway, like the invoice getting paid, or put one person in charge of it.

Who this is for. If you want 50 reviews by Friday, close this tab. Nobody can sell you that without putting your profile at risk. If you finish five or more jobs a month and want your phone ringing off a profile that’s fresh every week, this is your system.

FAQ

Can you ask for a review while you’re still on the job?

Yes, you can ask. Google says businesses shouldn’t “require or pressure users to leave ratings or write reviews while on the premises.” So ask, hand over the link, and don’t stand there while they type.

What if a competitor leaves you a fake review?

Report it. Google says: “If you find a review on your Business Profile that violates Google policies, you can report it for removal” (Google Business Profile Help). It “typically takes several days.” One contractor on Reddit, fighting a fake review on a lead site, wrote: “This ‘customer’ does not exist in our database and never has.” Keep records like that. Then reply calmly, because the next homeowner reads your reply.

Can you delete a bad review yourself?

No. You can report a review that breaks Google’s rules. If it’s a real customer with a real complaint, reply, fix it if you can, and keep the good ones coming.

Can you send a 1 to 5 star survey first?

Only if the Google link goes out to all of them, no matter what they score. If a low score sends them to a private form instead, that’s gating.

Do the same rules apply to Yelp?

Yelp is stricter. Yelp tells businesses not to ask for reviews at all. The guide on Yelp, Apple Business and Bing Places covers it.

Do these rules apply in Canada?

Yes. Google’s review policy has no Canada exception, and the Competition Bureau has its own warning on fake and employee reviews.


Want to know if the way you ask for reviews right now would pass? Book The Unfair Advantage Call. On an Apex build, the Clean Ask runs inside your CRM: every finished job, one text, no gate. You talk to John, not a sales rep. If your setup’s already clean, he’ll tell you that and you’re done.


John Milne

Founder of Apex ACQ, based in West Kelowna, BC. I build the page, the ads and the follow-up for home service contractors in the US and Canada. My best-known result: a tiny home builder that went from about $700K a month to over $2M a month in six months. No fluff, no corporate speak.