Service Area Pages for Contractors: What Ranks
Most contractor town pages shouldn’t exist. Yours might be one of them.
You’ve seen it. A roofer’s site with 40 pages: “Roofing in Town A,” “Roofing in Town B,” same words, town name swapped. Somebody sold them that. Here’s what Google actually says about it, and what a town page that earns calls looks like.
TL;DR: Google calls pages “targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page” doorway pages, and treats them as spam (Google Search Central). Its 2024 updates cut low-quality, unoriginal content in results by 45% (Google). Build a town page only where you’ve done real work, and prove it on the page with jobs, photos and reviews from that town.
What does Google say about town pages?
Google’s spam rules name “multiple domain names or pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page” as doorway spam (Google Search Central; Google, 2015). The same rules cover “scaled content abuse”: pumping out lots of pages to game rankings, however they’re made.
That’s not a ban on town pages. It’s a ban on fake ones. A page is fine if a homeowner in that town lands on it and it’s the useful last stop, not a detour to your contact form.
How much did Google’s crackdown actually hit?
A lot. Google expected its March 2024 changes to cut low-quality, unoriginal content in results by 40%. It reported 45% (Google). Copy-paste town pages are the kind of thing those changes went after.
So the “40 town pages” play isn’t just weak now. It can drag down the pages that were working.
What makes a town page worth building?
Proof from that town. Whitespark’s guide to service-area pages lists what strong ones carry: reviews from that town, a gallery of real jobs there, a map of where you work, your licences and insurance, and clear ways to call (Whitespark). Search Engine Land’s guide makes the same point: unique, useful content per area, not a template (Search Engine Land).
Here’s the test we use before building one:
- Have you done real jobs there? Not “we’d go there.” Jobs, with photos.
- Do you have a review from someone there? One real review signed with the town beats 500 words about the town.
- Is there something local to say? Permits, weather, old housing stock, the hill everyone’s driveway is on. Something a homeowner there would nod at.
Three yeses, build it. Fewer, skip it for now and put the effort into your main service pages.
Which pages should I build first?
One page per real service, before any town pages. A homeowner searching “panel upgrade” wants a page about panel upgrades, with what it costs, how long it takes and what can go wrong. Start there. Then add town pages where you’ve got the proof above.
If you’re not sure your site is the problem, check where your leads are going first. Our cost per lead guide shows what a healthy number looks like, and why your Google leads aren’t converting covers the leaks after the click.
Do town pages help me show up in the Map Pack?
Not directly. The Map Pack runs off your Google Business Profile, your reviews and how close you are to the searcher. Your site helps, but it’s not the main lever. The Map Pack playbook covers that side. Town pages mostly help the regular results below the map, and they help when a homeowner is comparing you to the next guy. One carpenter said it plain: “Quoted a deck at a fair price at around 20k and found that I lost the job to a company 2.5k higher than my bid.” The homeowner picked the one they trusted more. Local proof on the page is part of that.
The honest bit
A real town page takes work. You need the job photos, you need the review, you need to say something true about the place. That’s the point. If it was easy to copy, Google wouldn’t trust it. Most contractors would get more out of one good service page and a steady stream of reviews than out of ten new town pages.
FAQ
How many town pages should a contractor have?
As many as you can prove. If you’ve got real jobs, photos and a review in five towns, that’s five pages. If you’ve got proof in one, start with one.
Can I use the same page and just change the town name?
No. That’s the pattern Google’s spam rules describe. Each page needs content that’s actually about that town and your work there.
Will town pages get me calls from towns I don’t serve?
They can, and that’s a problem. Only build pages for towns you’ll actually drive to. A call from 3 hours away you can’t take is a wasted lead.
Should I delete my old copy-paste town pages?
Look at them one by one. If a page gets real visits and calls, rewrite it with real local proof. If it gets nothing, it’s a good candidate to fold into your main service page.
Want a second set of eyes on your site and where the leads are leaking? Book The Unfair Advantage Call and John will go through it with you.